Eagles Backfield
When I first heard that Chip Kelly traded LeSean McCoy to Buffalo for a linebacker I thought he was an idiot. Then I started to really get excited about McCoy’s fantasy value on a Rex Ryan Bills team. Fast forward about a week, and Chip goes and makes another couple of bonehead moves by signing both DeMarco Murray AND Ryan Mathews. Okay, so from a pure football point of view they weren’t necessarily bonehead moves (it can never hurt to have spoil of riches in your backfield), but as a fantasy fanatic I’m devastated that I can no longer think about drafting two of the running backs who I happen to have a certain affinity for. Let’s not forget that the Eagles still have Darren Sproles as well, adding more confusion to the jumbled mess of running backs in Philadelphia.
Heading into the 2015 fantasy season I would recommend avoiding all three backs entirely, but if I absolutely had to pick one of them to draft I would go with Sproles. Sproles is the guy who already has a year under his belt in Chip Kelly’s system, and he’s used to his role as a complimentary back. He has put up consistent production his entire career as a backup, even having to deal with teammates like LaDainian Tomlinson, Pierre Thomas, Chris Ivory, Mark Ingram, and McCoy. Darren Sproles is the one player that I can draft and at least feel confident that I know what I’m going to get. You should be able to wait until at least the 8th/9th round, or later, to draft a player who is still a decent FLEX consideration most weeks.
Sproles has only missed five games over the last five seasons (with San Diego, New Orleans and Philadelphia). He has 30 total TDs in that span, and averages 59 carries for 333 yards as well as 66 catches for 578 yards. He’s scored 220 fantasy points in his last two seasons (split between the Saints and Eagles), averaging 275 rushing yards and 495 receiving yards, with 12 total TDs. I am projecting Sproles will get 50 carries for 250 yards, 30 catches for 275 yards, 4 total TDs, and 75 fantasy points in 2015, which is a little more than a 30% drop from his average of 110 points over the past two seasons.
Unlike Sproles, Mathews and Murray are both new to this Eagles team and to Chip Kelly’s offense. Both backs have had a history of injuries (each RB has only played a complete 16-game season once in his career), and when they do play they are used to being “the guy”. The coach has been very open about his plan to split the workload as much as possible and use all of his backs, and for that reason I believe we could see a lot of “feast or famine” output in this timeshare. Think of it like this: Sproles may still be the 3rd RB on the team, but you can expect him to consistently put up 6 points per week, whereas Murray and Mathews will take turns having impact games depending on who’s hot at the time. This, of course, is also assuming that there are no injury setbacks for either player (DeMarco Murray in particular).
Tristan H. Cockroft wrote an amazing article in 2010 about the “370 curse” (basically dooming any RBs who have carried the ball 370 times or more in one season), and DeMarco Murray is definitely the next big name back who can fall victim to this. Sure, you may not be one to place too much value on silly things like curses, but there is more than enough evidence in the stats to back up this idea, and Cockroft really does a tremendous job outlining all of the key contributors to what will most likely be a huge fantasy flop for Murray this season. My projections for DeMarco: 205 carries and 35 catches for 1,230 total yards, with 7 TDs and 160 fantasy points. Those numbers would again be around a 30% drop from his 2013-2014 average of 236 fantasy points, and are much more generous than what Cockroft’s research would suggest.
I guess 30% is the magic number because I also anticipate Ryan Mathews’ output to drop off by right around that figure. His draft stock is the most unpredictable in my opinion for a number of reasons. First, he’s the most fragile back on this list and only played 6 games in 2014. Second, I feel like a lot of fantasy owners might be inclined to reach too much for Mathews by overestimating the upside provided by the Eagles offensive scheme. Finally (and this is admittedly all speculation on my part), this is the first time in four years that he has had to compete for a starting job, and let’s face it the San Diego media/ fan base isn’t exactly Philly. I have to wonder a little bit about how he will hold up mentally if he struggles on the field, and it could ultimately derail his fantasy season as well. I see him getting 120 carries and 20 catches for 675 total yards, with 3 TDs and 85 fantasy points. Over the last two years, he’s averaged 121 points and has produced a total of 1,843 yards and 10 TDs on 394 touches (which is right on pace with the 1,845 yards that Murray had on 393 carries in 2014).
Sincerely, The Jeggernaut-